The suggestion has merit and should warrant serious consideration by the devs.

individual players already have the option to "Recall All" from their garrison list.  The OP's suggestion is merely the inverse, allowing the league leadership levels to decide whether or not to commit league resources to a defense or to get them out of potential harm's way and save them for a better time, place, or opportunity.

Register my vote as "aye" for both League Marshal and Captains.

Good Hunting!

NO I don't agree

giving one player a control of someone else troops, that is blatant dictatorship. Only leagues that function on the principles of dictatorship will agree for these

NO NO NO 

Not that my vote matters, in three weeks the post will be locked( I hope in less days) 

oracle said:

NO I don't agree

giving one player a control of someone else troops, that is blatant dictatorship. Only leagues that function on the principles of dictatorship will agree for these

NO NO NO 

Not that my vote matters, in three weeks the post will be locked( I hope in less days) 

first the only control shall be on the units in beacon or fortress 

 In concept, this is a great idea. Think about how this would be abused however, then this becomes a bad idea. A disgruntled Captain could wipe all the units from all the Beacons before he leaves the League.  This power would be best if Captains/Marshals could move members' units who are "Long Ago".  No more headaches during Beacon swaps in the Holidays!!!    :)

I vote yes, but only if an auto catacomb is included for returning troops.

 In concept, this is a great idea. Think about how this would be abused however, then this becomes a bad idea. A disgruntled Captain could wipe all the units from all the Beacons before he leaves the League.  This power would be best if Captains/Marshals could move members' units who are "Long Ago".  No more headaches during Beacon swaps in the Holidays!!!    :)

I would still say "Yes" is my Vote.

Good idea. +1

I agree:

1) Both fortress' and beacons need to have "The Button."

2) "The Button" should be all inclusive for the fortress/beacon  *AND*  one for selecting all of an individual member's troops.

3) Only the Marshall and those Captains that the Marshall designates should have rights to the buttons.

4) All returned troops should go directly to the catacombs.

   The reasons behind these buttons makes perfect sense.  This game is a world-wide game and several leagues have members scattered across different time-zones.  Not all member's speak the same language and online translators are imperfect when it comes to translating important league affecting messages.  On top of that, each league has members with varying levels of activity; we all have real lives that effect our ability to play consistently.  The Marshall *NEEDS* to have the ability to make league wide changes in a timely manner, regardless of player circumstances I've listed above.  And the Marshall can't be expected to do everything for their league by themselves, so allowing *TRUSTED* Captains rights to help the Marshall only makes sense.  However Plarium envisioned the beacons to function (transferable or not) doesn't matter when in practice they are used in a diplomatic fashion (as well as the fortresses when it comes to upgrades/downgrades), so to keep the enjoyment of the game for new and old players, "The Buttons" need to happen.

-Looney DaLoon

Captain of Dark Solace

oracle said:

NO I don't agree

giving one player a control of someone else troops, that is blatant dictatorship. Only leagues that function on the principles of dictatorship will agree for these

NO NO NO 

Not that my vote matters, in three weeks the post will be locked( I hope in less days) 

if you cant trust your marshal and captains then you in the wrong league .... this is just my opinion

with that being said i agree there should be a button to send back troops .... it will avoid players losing troops for no reason

either way if a marshal or captain wanted to get rid of people of beacons there is a button to boot players which would basically remove there troops from beacons ....... so all the button will do is keep them in the league and protect them from others