You will have to fill the bank before you get a reward. 

However, even if your bank is full, you will have to meet the requirement to trigger a spin in your favour. 

But, everytime you try to spin the BG spin in your favour, you inflate your bank. 

Inflating your bank increase the chance of a payout, but decrease the chance of a BG spin going your favour. 

And, you pay a BG tax, every time you do this. Which is crazy. Most people say the BG tax is between 1-8%. To put it in perspective, for every 100 dragons you send to the Battleground, 8 are forever lost. 

So yes, BG are one tidy mess, that eat your army over time. But if you buy sapphires and revive those units in the healer, you can increase your army by 8000-1500% per month. But that will cost you R55 000 or more. 

to make more clearly my questions, why have some players bgs been changed around 6 months ago but not all players?and what exaclty defined thoose players from the rest of players?

What server are you playing on?

I play on Dark Plains .com server.

I can 100% assure that BG's are working as normal on my server. In fact other than adding more levels they haven't made ANY changes to BGs for years. 

That is from tricking 100+ of my own accounts, many more of other people's and frequently using BG's to swap offence for defence. There is literally not a week when I haven't put at least 2/3 accounts through BGs (a lot more normally). I have resource tracked 10k+ BG's, on many accounts, and recently did a few hundred to re-check the BG tax (which came out at 3-4% btw).

Unless you track resource in and out of your BG's then it's pointless to make any comments about BG's.

Comparing your payouts to other people's is utterly pointless. As explained by Oracle, the size of the payouts is going to be unique to each player depending on what they loaded previous to the payout.

If you were to publish a BG resource log I could tell you whether your BG's were working as expected and explain the parts of it you didn't understand (within reason cause I am not going to expose all the BG's mechanics here).

If you can't be bothered to create a resource log, then just post screenshots of the BG hits/payouts and I'll probably get off by backside and do it for you and show they are working fine (or prove that there is an issue that is unique to your server).

FYI I invented the BG trick it sounds like your trying to use. Back in 2016, the last time they made a major change to BGs.

If you still have the BG reports on any account you think got bad results, then post then (or PM them to me). If reports have been deleted then run BG's again and then send the reports.

I'll take a look at it, put them in a BG resource tracking spreadsheet (I have a very easy to use one in Google docs).

It will either prove conclusively that there is an issue or help explain what is happening that you didn't expect.

It would be helpful to know whether the screenshots are from an accounts that already reached 210 and you are playing BG's "normally" on, or whether you were still going up in levels and what the top level BGs was on the account at the start of the screenshots.

This is the last account I tracked resource on.

I don't remember exactly when it was done but it was DEFINITELY in the last 6 months. All working as expected.

Each BG is split into two rows, the loading on one line and the payout on the next. The Banked column is the resource value of the troops (you put in the troop number across the page and it calculated the resource value of the troops automatically in the Banked coluimn).

FYI the loading is shown as positive, the payouts as negative. So  if you have anything in your BG bank then it's positive.

FYI 205, is the first BG in the log. So the cumulative column starts from the start of the screenshot. There was obviously a little bit in the bank at that point because the first BG gives about a 50m profit. If the cumulative column is negative, you actually make a profit on the BGs.

That is the spreadsheet I can put your screenshots in (FYI it has other info in it, like avg banking value of the BGs - which I have hidden)

Do you have an account that you think is broken that you are willing to allow me on?

I'll do some BG's tracking on it and publish the results here.

I'll either get your troops back, or we'll prove your point with a drop log that is absolute evidence.

FYI for the process to be quick and easy, the account would need enough troops on it to kill a 210 (14/15m defence or up to about 30/40m off - can be much less depending on the Balur troop match ups) and still have some left to do BG's after that. The more troops the better, so I can quickly do BG's. If it's really small I'll have to continually be thinking about how not to get the troops stuck and it will be really slow and painful.

You can delete your card details. It's just extremely un-intuitive how you go about doing it. 

You have to:

- click the little pen icon to the left of the card details

- when that is highlighted, there is a red cross to the right of card details that allow you to delete the card details for that card

- BUT you have to go an click the pen icon again for the process to complete (it unhighlights and then the card details disappear). 

Only after the final step will you see the details removed. Even though it looks like you have completed the process when you click the red cross you haven't and next time you log in card details will still be there (that is assuming you even thought to click the pen thing in the first place)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

With regards to the BG's..... the problem you are up against is that they have people complaining about BG's probably every day (very very frequently). And all of those people are people that don't know what they are talking about and are just frustrated or upset they have lost troops.

Unless you give them a very clear log of your BG activity you are going to get nowhere trying to convince them there is a problem. They will just assume you are one of the very long line of ppl claiming things are broken when they aren't.

Being totally honest, I won't believe you either without evidence. So many have claimed in the past to know what they are talking about, only in the end for it to turn out they haven't got a clue. So you'll have a credibility issue, unless you can provide hard evidence.

If you want to try one more account and make a log, let me know and I'll find a way help you do it.

No worries. If you mail me in game from your main we'll start the convo.