Winnings of CvC should directly go to StrongHold

7 Replies
User
21 September, 2018, 5:55 PM UTC

All jarls work hard to win a CvC. 


It is painful for owner to send winnings to the stronghold. If StrongHold Exists the winnings of CvC should deposit directly to StrongHold.


UTC +7:00
2
User
21 September, 2018, 8:59 PM UTC

Glad you qualified it with, IF there is a stronghold, otherwise I was going to ask for one.


Though all jarls  might work hard for the win, some are more productive than others, and the reward might be used in such a way to address that.


Sending the reward directly to a stronghold would remove this option.


The text says the reward for winning is for clan development. So surely its best left up to the clan to decide what that is.





UTC +0:00
0
User
22 September, 2018, 11:30 AM UTC

And if transferring the resources is becoming too burdensome, transfer power to a different member once in a while. 

Mandating where the winnings go is not the answer though.

UTC +7:00
0
User
22 September, 2018, 9:07 PM UTC

It is just a royal waste of time for anyone to transfer resources. We are talking about 2B rss to be transferred. It takes forever. 

Now here is what truly happens. CvC is all about who can spend the most $$ in most cases. Train troops, SH transformations, very few fights. The amount of rss consumed to do SH transformations or to train troops by each of top contributors easily goes in Billions and top performers sacrifice for the clan to contribute to SH and send rss to others. 


I do see the point where people may want to use winnings differently. So it should be an OPTION to chose where to deposit winnings? Specific town or SH. May be define % share?



I just find current system very inefficient. 
UTC +7:00
2
User
23 September, 2018, 12:00 AM UTC

Could there not simply be a checkbox in the "Management" tab of the "Clans" page?

Something like: "Deliver CvC Resource winnings to Clan Stronghold".

If you would like to get fancy you could add for example:

  • Percentage or amount slider (amount of each RSS to be handed over to SH / Chief)
  • RSS type selector (Send for example Silver and Stone to SH rest to chief)
  • Recipient selector (instead of chief)
  • etc.

But that would merely be sugar.

This option would obviously not be available for clans without a SH.

I get that loads of the tasks in this game is meant to have a effort-factor, but this; for Chief to have to spend tons of time sending winnings to SH, is IMHO a loss loss feature. Can not see any upside the way it is, and no downside implementing a feature like this.


As a sub-note:

You could, of course, apply the tax on the RSS if delivered directly to SH, but rather would see not (of course lol). The winnings are not "That Great" considering the amount of resources many clans put down winning these events.


Thank you.

UTC +2:00
2
User
23 September, 2018, 12:05 AM UTC

Its now clearer what you meant.

Rather than painful, which I took to mean something else,you mightve have said, its time consuming to do, something which could be fixed in other ways.

Must agree about the lack of real competition in the competitions.

The competitions are mostly a ruse anyway, players shouldnt need an additional incentive to do all those things you mention. 

One way of solving the problem, is dont take part, another is make sure you loose.

You are actually winning a nice amount of resources.

 

You  mention you  win billions but you also say you spend billions.

Where is the profit and the sense of it all?

UTC +0:00
1
CIM
User
23 September, 2018, 3:33 AM UTC
We don't always send the winnings to the stronghold ... since we have hyperfarms that feed the stronghold.  So a lot of times we just put the winnings in the appropriate "bank" and since it is possible to send large amounts of rss to clan members then it doesn't take so long to get rid of 2B resources.  When the chief and the main banks sit around the stronghold it can take less than 10 minutes to get rid of the winnings.
UTC +1:00
1
User
26 September, 2018, 7:40 PM UTC

Jarl_007 said:


All jarls work hard to win a CvC. 


It is painful for owner to send winnings to the stronghold. If StrongHold Exists the winnings of CvC should deposit directly to StrongHold.


I second this motion. Those of you with billions of RSS from your "hyper farms" need not shoot this idea down! Sending rewards directly to the Stronghold would save time as well as make sure those resources go 100% to benefit the clan. Sending them to the chief when there is already a Stronghold in place means giving up a large chunk of those hard earned rewards in taxes, unless of course your chief doesn't share with the clan and has no motivation to assist with the growth of its members or stronghold. (I figure a clan under that rule has got more serious problems than taxed rewards at any rate so my statement isn't for those unlucky few)


I really think the idea of tax in this game should be done away with altogether, but until that beautiful day arrives, it would be a better practice to allow Clans to benefit from the full extent of their rewards. The only way to do that is to send CVC RSS winnings directly to the stronghold storage. (SH storage meaning the chief if SH is not yet constructed)
MizBiz
UTC +5:00
2
2708264 users registered; 70933 topics; 354245 posts; our newest member:Juan