This topic is closed

The reward system on Battlegrounds is now secure against attempts to obtain Units in an unfair way!

310 Replies
cat in the hat
8 July, 2016, 8:22 PM UTC
Battle grounds were never a way to get a profit off for a long time. Anyone who got brain washed to think it was what to do is probably still doing them going for more losses. The people who spent money to lose there army to lose about 20% of what they put in to it was not thinking to well.
UTC +6:00
0
Techway_GrandMarshal
9 July, 2016, 7:53 AM UTC

It's amazing how the mod's here don't answer all these questions.


its a real shame!


UTC +0:00
0
Valheru
9 July, 2016, 3:45 PM UTC

There was absolutely no vulnerability in the battleground system

once again ignorance and greed has won the day! and yes you did in fact reset my bank all those resources lost

thank you appreciate it!!

UTC +2:00
0
Vladimir Stojanovic
9 July, 2016, 9:01 PM UTC

Techway_GrandMarshal said:


It's amazing how the mod's here don't answer all these questions.



its a real shame!

Because we do not want to turn the discussion in the opposite direction my Lord

UTC +2:00
0
Vladimir Stojanovic
9 July, 2016, 9:06 PM UTC

Valheru said:


There was absolutely no vulnerability in the battleground system

once again ignorance and greed has won the day! and yes you did in fact reset my bank all those resources lost

thank you appreciate it!!

My Lord I can assure you that the Bank has not be reseted, you had wrong insight into the bank.

UTC +2:00
0
mujo
10 July, 2016, 7:45 AM UTC

i have done some 100 BG since the new system has been implemented, and I can say i got NOTHING. just a few dwarves 2-6 or 2 paladin, or pikeman,

Stay AWAY from BGS, its now totally, broken, 

Before when i did the BG, i eventually got a reward,  i did then one after the next, NOW I GET NOTHING.

My Advice, i play everyday, is stay away from BGS, its done, i confirmed this with my league. and allies.

UTC +1:00
0
mujo
10 July, 2016, 9:29 AM UTC

I wanted to be clear about my feedback on the New Battle Ground:

1. I have gotten zero rewards often since the remake, even though i lost many many troops,

2. Your claim that if i did not lose any troops , only then i get no reward is wrong and false and misleading.

3. Before only did the BG one after the other, and almost always got a reward after a few that was a 'trade-up' for example pikeman to paldin or knights.etc.

4 Now i get nothing and i have done over 60 battle grounds since the Re-Do and GOT NOTHING, but a few dwarves (2-3) and other junk like 

for 100 paladin 6 paldin reward, 

5. I suggest NO ONE DO THE BATTLEGROUND ANYMORE.

6. Whatever so called 'scam or bug' claim to have fixed, you also destroyed the rewards for those who knew nothing about this bug and therefore never exploited it.

7. So to recap for the last 3 days, i have gotten nothing from the Battlegrounds and my allies and league members have had the same experience.


UTC +1:00
2
mujo
10 July, 2016, 11:10 AM UTC

just a quick update, after another 20 BGS, got only 2 knights and 2 pikeman, 

WARNING: BG are no longer part of the game of me, they are DEAD.

better to save your troops.

UTC +1:00
0
Inaginni
10 July, 2016, 1:23 PM UTC

mujo said:


just a quick update, after another 20 BGS, got only 2 knights and 2 pikeman, 

WARNING: BG are no longer part of the game of me, they are DEAD.

better to save your troops.

I did bgs not even a week ago (during exp tourney) and got about 98% of what I put in back out.

Edit: If you haven't already started doing it, an easy way to get large payouts is to break them from top to bottom. I have not tested to see if doing this is more advantageous in the end than going bottom up though.

If you go bottom up it can be hard to get the larger payouts as the small payouts can keep you below the minimum amount for a large payout. Going bottom up could require two sets of bgs being done before getting a large payout.
UTC +0:00
0
wesleypringle1
10 July, 2016, 2:13 PM UTC

jmcnamee said:


The new system does not work as advertised.  I have completed a number of BG's without receiving troops as a reward.


It's possible only if you had zero losses on them.
No true I have loss but No troops as reward Contrary to the reply 

The Keep
UTC +4:00
0
mujo
10 July, 2016, 4:42 PM UTC

what  a joke, every time some , including me says: 

The new system does not work as advertised. I have completed a number of BG's without receiving troops as a reward.


There is a standard REPLY posted in bold yellow letters:


It's possible only if you had zero losses on them.

as if BOLD YELLOW LETTERS make LIES BELIEVEABLE ??????

UTC +1:00
0
mujo
10 July, 2016, 4:45 PM UTC

Inaginni said:


mujo said:


just a quick update, after another 20 BGS, got only 2 knights and 2 pikeman, 

WARNING: BG are no longer part of the game of me, they are DEAD.

better to save your troops.

I did bgs not even a week ago (during exp tourney) and got about 98% of what I put in back out.

Edit: If you haven't already started doing it, an easy way to get large payouts is to break them from top to bottom. I have not tested to see if doing this is more advantageous in the end than going bottom up though.

If you go bottom up it can be hard to get the larger payouts as the small payouts can keep you below the minimum amount for a large payout. Going bottom up could require two sets of bgs being done before getting a large payout.

A week ago?? you sure, sounds like your having my experience BEFORE THE BG WAS REDONE. 

why dont you do that right now and then post your results.

get the time and facts straight mate .)
UTC +1:00
0
Shibu
10 July, 2016, 5:24 PM UTC
You win, I'm gone!
UTC +5:00
0
brunsonthomas
10 July, 2016, 5:30 PM UTC
The only levels I do not get troops from BGs is 7 and under. I don't lose any there either. Please include screen shot of levels where you are getting no return.
UTC +5:00
0
ion
10 July, 2016, 8:02 PM UTC

Inaginni said:


mujo said:


just a quick update, after another 20 BGS, got only 2 knights and 2 pikeman, 

WARNING: BG are no longer part of the game of me, they are DEAD.

better to save your troops.

I did bgs not even a week ago (during exp tourney) and got about 98% of what I put in back out.

Edit: If you haven't already started doing it, an easy way to get large payouts is to break them from top to bottom. I have not tested to see if doing this is more advantageous in the end than going bottom up though.

If you go bottom up it can be hard to get the larger payouts as the small payouts can keep you below the minimum amount for a large payout. Going bottom up could require two sets of bgs being done before getting a large payout.

98%??-maybe a year ago

Most of players seems to lose more after the changes were made (including myself- i calculated 65-85% return, depending the level of BGs))
aaa
UTC +0:00
0
Inaginni
10 July, 2016, 10:38 PM UTC
ion said:

Inaginni said:


mujo said:


just a quick update, after another 20 BGS, got only 2 knights and 2 pikeman, 

WARNING: BG are no longer part of the game of me, they are DEAD.

better to save your troops.

I did bgs not even a week ago (during exp tourney) and got about 98% of what I put in back out.

Edit: If you haven't already started doing it, an easy way to get large payouts is to break them from top to bottom. I have not tested to see if doing this is more advantageous in the end than going bottom up though.

If you go bottom up it can be hard to get the larger payouts as the small payouts can keep you below the minimum amount for a large payout. Going bottom up could require two sets of bgs being done before getting a large payout.

98%??-maybe a year ago

Most of players seems to lose more after the changes were made (including myself- i calculated 65-85% return, depending the level of BGs))
Nah for sure I got 98%. Before the update I was still making a profit somehow, about 120-160% (usually around 130%) out on lvl 30- bgs, much to the confusion of my KoK buds (my numbers were checked by others to make sure). We never figured out exactly what in my method was causing it, as there was nothing special besides my bgs being low level and me not using bestiary units ever. Now it seems my bgs have been lowered down so oh well I guess. 98% makes it still worthwhile for converting, though.
UTC +0:00
0
Drogar61
10 July, 2016, 10:43 PM UTC
160% of what? Resources or strength?
UTC +0:00
0
Inaginni
10 July, 2016, 10:51 PM UTC
Drogar61 said:

160% of what? Resources or strength?
Ah yes I should have specified. Resources for sure. The 160% was a one time high though.
UTC +0:00
0
Drogar61
10 July, 2016, 11:03 PM UTC

Strange, and very probably you made mistake in calculation, or you found really ugly bug in algorithm.

UTC +0:00
1
Inaginni
11 July, 2016, 1:17 AM UTC

Drogar61 said:


Strange, and very probably you made mistake in calculation, or you found really ugly bug in algorithm.

Was probably a bug since I'm pretty sure we weren't supposed to be able to make a profit anymore. As I said before though, other members of the KoK family checked it as well and got the same result.

Background in case you don't know: It would probably be fair to say that the KoK family is an expert with respect to bgs.

UTC +0:00
0
1775809 users registered; 47830 topics; 285588 posts; our newest member:Commander 2816856