In the most feared pirate contest, you said the contest will last only 1 day which logically means a 24-hour contest. Since you initiated the contest at 11 Dec 12:36pm UTC, the last comment posted on or before said deadline should have won, and yet you awarded the reward to someone who posted way beyond the 1 day / 24-hour contest deadline. In winner's own post, she even admitted to not following the rule as to the deadline. Clearly this is not fair and puts the integrity of your contest rules in question. I suppose this means you have unbridled discretion in who to award rewards to and in ignoring your own rules. I hope this isn't some kind of unfair favouritism for a preferred player going on here.